Verification Academy

Search form

My Account Menu

  • Register
  • Log In
  • Topics
  • Courses
  • Forums
  • Patterns Library
  • Cookbooks
  • Events
  • More
  • All Topics
    The Verification Academy offers users multiple entry points to find the information they need. One of these entry points is through Topic collections. These topics are industry standards that all design and verification engineers should recognize. While we continue to add new topics, users are encourage to further refine collection information to meet their specific interests.
    • Languages & Standards

      • Portable Test and Stimulus
      • Functional Safety
      • Design & Verification Languages
    • Methodologies

      • UVM - Universal Verification Methodology
      • UVM Framework
      • UVM Connect
      • FPGA Verification
      • Coverage
    • Techniques & Tools

      • Verification IP
      • Simulation-Based Techniques
      • Planning, Measurement, and Analysis
      • Formal-Based Techniques
      • Debug
      • Clock-Domain Crossing
      • Acceleration
  • All Courses
    The Verification Academy is organized into a collection of free online courses, focusing on various key aspects of advanced functional verification. Each course consists of multiple sessions—allowing the participant to pick and choose specific topics of interest, as well as revisit any specific topics for future reference. After completing a specific course, the participant should be armed with enough knowledge to then understand the necessary steps required for maturing their own organization’s skills and infrastructure on the specific topic of interest. The Verification Academy will provide you with a unique opportunity to develop an understanding of how to mature your organization’s processes so that you can then reap the benefits that advanced functional verification offers.
    • Universal Verification Methodology (UVM)

      • Advanced UVM
      • Basic UVM
      • Introduction to UVM
      • UVM Connect
      • UVM Debug
      • UVMF - One Bite at a Time
    • Featured Courses

      • Introduction to ISO 26262
      • Introduction to DO-254
      • Clock-Domain Crossing Verification
      • Portable Stimulus Basics
      • Power Aware CDC Verification
      • Power Aware Verification
      • SystemVerilog OOP for UVM Verification
    • Additional Courses

      • Assertion-Based Verification
      • An Introduction to Unit Testing with SVUnit
      • Evolving FPGA Verification Capabilities
      • Metrics in SoC Verification
      • SystemVerilog Testbench Acceleration
      • Testbench Co-Emulation: SystemC & TLM-2.0
      • Verification Planning and Management
      • VHDL-2008 Why It Matters
    • Formal-Based Techniques

      • Formal Assertion-Based Verification
      • Formal-Based Technology: Automatic Formal Solutions
      • Formal Coverage
      • Getting Started with Formal-Based Technology
      • Handling Inconclusive Assertions in Formal Verification
      • Sequential Logic Equivalence Checking
    • Analog/Mixed Signal

      • AMS Design Configuration Schemes
      • Improve AMS Verification Performance
      • Improve AMS Verification Quality
  • All Forum Topics
    The Verification Community is eager to answer your UVM, SystemVerilog and Coverage related questions. We encourage you to take an active role in the Forums by answering and commenting to any questions that you are able to.
    • UVM Forum

      • Active Questions
      • Solutions
      • Replies
      • No Replies
      • Search
      • UVM Forum
    • SystemVerilog Forum

      • Active Questions
      • Solutions
      • Replies
      • No Replies
      • Search
      • SystemVerilog Forum
    • Coverage Forum

      • Active Questions
      • Solutions
      • Replies
      • No Replies
      • Search
      • Coverage Forum
    • Additional Forums

      • Announcements
      • Downloads
      • OVM Forum
  • Patterns Library
    The Verification Academy Patterns Library contains a collection of solutions to many of today's verification problems. The patterns contained in the library span across the entire domain of verification (i.e., from specification to methodology to implementation—and across multiple verification engines such as formal, simulation, and emulation).
    • Implementation Patterns

      • Environment Patterns
      • Stimulus Patterns
      • Analysis Patterns
      • All Implementation Patterns
    • Specification Patterns

      • Occurrence Property Patterns
      • Order Property Patterns
      • All Specification Patterns
    • Pattern Resources

      • Start Here - Patterns Library Overview
      • Whitepaper - Taking Reuse to the Next Level
      • Verification Horizons - The Verification Academy Patterns Library
      • Contribute a Pattern to the Library
  • All Cookbooks
    Find all the methodology you need in this comprehensive and vast collection. The UVM and Coverage Cookbooks contain dozens of informative, executable articles covering all aspects of UVM and Coverage.
    • UVM Cookbook

      • UVM Basics
      • Testbench Architecture
      • DUT-Testbench Connections
      • Configuring a Test Environment
      • Analysis Components & Techniques
      • End Of Test Mechanisms
      • Sequences
      • The UVM Messaging System
      • Other Stimulus Techniques
      • Register Abstraction Layer
      • Testbench Acceleration through Co-Emulation
      • Debug of SV and UVM
      • UVM Connect - SV-SystemC interoperability
      • UVM Versions and Compatibility
      • UVM Cookbook
    • Coding Guidelines & Deployment

      • Code Examples
      • UVM Verification Component
      • Package/Organization
      • Questa/Compiling UVM
      • SystemVerilog Guidelines
      • SystemVerilog Performance Guidelines
      • UVM Guidelines
      • UVM Performance Guidelines
    • Coverage Cookbook

      • Introduction
      • What is Coverage?
      • Kinds of Coverage
      • Specification to Testplan
      • Testplan to Functional Coverage
      • Bus Protocol Coverage
      • Block Level Coverage
      • Datapath Coverage
      • SoC Coverage Example
      • Requirements Writing Guidelines
      • Coverage Cookbook
  • All Events
    No one argues that the challenges of verification are growing exponentially. What is needed to meet these challenges are tools, methodologies and processes that can help you transform your verification environment. These recorded seminars from Verification Academy trainers and users provide examples for adoption of new technologies and how to evolve your verification process.
    • Upcoming & Featured Events

      • Low Power Verification - 4/29
      • Fault Campaign for Mixed-Signal - 5/4
      • User2User - 5/26
      • Webinar Calendar
    • On-Demand Webinars

      • CDC+RDC Analysis
      • Basic Abstraction Techniques
      • Safety Analysis Techniques
      • QVIP Workflow and Debug for PCIe
      • Writing a Proxy-driven Testbench
      • Achieving High Defect Coverage
      • Visualizer Features
      • All On-Demand Webinars
    • Recording Archive

      • Siemens EDA 2021 Functional Verification Webinar Series
      • Improving Your SystemVerilog & UVM Skills
      • Should I Kill My Formal Run?
      • Visualizer Debug Environment
      • Industry Data & Surveys
      • All Recordings
    • Conferences

      • DVCon 2021
      • DVCon 2020
      • DAC 2019
      • All Conferences
    • Mentor Learning Center

      • SystemVerilog Fundamentals
      • SystemVerilog UVM
      • View all Learning Paths
  • About Verification Academy
    The Verification Academy will provide you with a unique opportunity to develop an understanding of how to mature your organization's processes so that you can then reap the benefits that advanced functional verification offers.
    • Blog & News

      • Verification Horizons Blog
      • Academy News
      • Academy Newsletter
      • Technical Resources
    • Verification Horizons Publication

      • Verification Horizons - March 2021
      • Verification Horizons - November 2020
      • Verification Horizons - July 2020
      • Issue Archive
    • About Us

      • Verification Academy Overview
      • Subject Matter Experts
      • Contact Us
    • Training

      • Questa Basic
      • Questa Advanced
      • Mastering Questa
Ask a Question
UVM
  • Home
  • Forums
  • UVM
  • [RAL] Problems with Memory Frontdoor Write

[RAL] Problems with Memory Frontdoor Write

UVM 5686
RAL 53 frontdoor 5 memory 5
sheila_hsu
sheila_hsu
Full Access
1 post
September 11, 2018 at 3:47 am

Hi all,
I'm trying to configure and verify my DUT via RAL. First, I write certain values to registers(or memory) through frontdoor access. Next, I read it through backdoor access and compare those values with the expected values.

class cfg_seq extends uvm_reg_sequence#(uvm_sequence#(data));
 
  // utils macro and constructor not shown
 
  ral_block_host_regmodel regmodel;
 
  virtual task body();
    uvm_status_e status;
    uvm_reg_data_t data;
 
    if(starting_phase != null)
        starting_phase.raise_objection(this);
 
    regmodel.LOCK.read(.status(status), .value(data), .path(UVM_BACKDOOR), .parent(this));
    if (data != 'hffff) begin
      `uvm_fatal("RAL_ERR", $sformatf("LOCK is %4h instead of 'hffff", data));
    end
    regmodel.LOCK.write(.status(status), .value('1), .path(UVM_FRONTDOOR), .parent(this));
    regmodel.LOCK.read(.status(status), .value(data), .path(UVM_BACKDOOR), .parent(this));
    if (data != '0) begin
      `uvm_fatal("RAL_ERR", $sformatf("LOCK is %4h instead of 'h0000", data));
    end else begin
      `uvm_info("RAL_TEST", $sformatf("LOCK is %4h the expected value is 'h0000", data), UVM_MEDIUM);
    end
 
    // Others register configurations not shown
 
    //===Verify memory by walking ones algorithm===
    // Write walking ones to the RAM
    for (int i=0; i<4096; i++) begin
      regmodel.RAM.write(.status(status), .offset(i), .value(16'b1 << i%16), .path(UVM_FRONTDOOR), .parent(this));
    end
 
    // Read back from the RAM and check the pattern
    for (int i=0; i<4096; i++) begin
      regmodel.RAM.read(.status(status), .offset(i), .value(data), .path(UVM_BACKDOOR), .parent(this));
      if (data != (16'b1 << i%16)) begin
        `uvm_fatal("RAL_ERR", $sformatf("RAM is %4h instead of %4h", data, 16'b1 << i%16));
      end
    end
    `uvm_info("RAL_TEST", "RAM contains the expected values", UVM_MEDIUM);
 
    if(starting_phase != null)
        starting_phase.drop_objection(this);
  endtask
endclass

Everything works fine except writing memory through frontdoor access. The valus read back from the RAM is the residual value instead of the expected.

At first, I thought there is something wrong with the frontdoor path;but, other writing through frontdoor accesse for registers worked fine. Hence, I did some experiments:

  1. FRONTDOOR write to the RAM, then FRONTDOOR read from the RAM
  2. BACKDOOR write to the RAM, then FRONTDOOR read from the RAM
  3. BACKDOOR write to the RAM, then BACKDOOR read from the RAM
Finally, I figured out that only "BACKDOOR write" will success.

I googled and found some similar problems:

  1. Issue when UVM Reg Frontdoor write followed by Backdoor read
  2. UVM Reg Frontdoor and Backdoor accesses
  3. difference in backdoor and frontdoor accessing of memory
These posts pointed out that the possible reason causes this may be the DUT or timing problem.
I suppose the issue is caused by timing problem(i.e., read operations were performed before write operations finished). If so, is there any mechanism can prevent from this issue? Or maybe isn't the timing problem?

I know that using backdoor access for memory is recommended, but I still want to know if there is a proper way to access memory through frontdoor access.
Any advise or hint is appreciated.

Thanks in advance,
Sheila

Replies

Log In to Reply
Siemens Digital Industries Software

Siemens Digital Industries Software

##TodayMeetsTomorrow

Solutions

  • Cloud
  • Mendix
  • Siemens EDA
  • MindSphere
  • Siemens PLM
  • View all portfolio

Explore

  • Digital Journeys
  • Community
  • Blog
  • Online Store

Siemens

  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Events
  • News and Press
  • Newsletter
  • Customer Stories

Contact Us

USA:

phone-office +1 800 547 3000

See our Worldwide Directory

  • Contact Us
  • Support Center
  • Give us Feedback
©2021 Siemens Digital Industries Software. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use Privacy Cookie Policy